Showing posts with label Fenian Raid - Fort Erie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fenian Raid - Fort Erie. Show all posts

Monday, July 30, 2007

Fenian Invasion Part 4

We know who the Fenians were. What should we do? Writers Note: We were not a nation yet in 1865 but we were not going to sit around and let the Fenians do as they pleased. In the weeks and months that followed the end of the Civil War we sent spies ( I’ll call them Canadians) to many northern American cities. The reports that came back were disturbing, There were increased Fenian activities in the winter of 1865-66. The spies heard again of grandiose schemes to attack Canada from Detroit and Rochester and take Upper Canada (Ontario). In Lower Canada (Quebec) armies would attack from Ogdensburg, Plattsburg and Portland and take Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and Quebec. The Fenian military strategy in both cases was to attack in s ‘pincers” movements.
Writer’s note: Lest we underestimate the Fenians remember they were mainly tried and hardened Civil War veterans. They had Spencer repeating rifles and superior equipment. We had not fought a war since 1812-14. We still used the old muzzle loading musket - the “Brown Bess” Once a year or so we would have a gathering of local militias. It appeared that the Canadian colonies would be no match for trained Civil War army veterans.
***
History often repeats itself. I believe that the Fenian leaders followed the same mind-set as other American invaders - that Canada was for the taking. “Blarney” is defined as smooth deceitful talk. I believe that the Fenians knew that to realize their dream of a new Irish Republic in North America they had to use the “Blarney” approach. Their method was to create in the minds of their “would-be” followers that such a grand scheme of theirs was possible. Using “blarney and more “blarney” would be their ploy.
***
The Fenian dream included this recorded statement” The Green flag will scour the bays and gulfs in Canada. A Fenian fleet from San Francisco will carry Vancouver and the Fraser River country.” Think big was the Fenian Brotherhood plans for Canada. What was reality? Again according to their documents of their war department (I.R.A.) we read, “ The Canadian and provincial borders once crossed bases of operation will be established in the enemy’s country so that the international quarrels with Washington may be avoided.” How? More “blarney” from the would-be invaders.
Next: The Invasion Plan

Fenian Invasion Part 3

Who were the Fenians? What about Canada? The Irish Fenian Brotherhood of North America were now split into two factions over their next move. At a meeting held in Chicago in 1863 the Roberts faction of the Brotherhood decided to seize Canada as a home for the Irish Republic. By the end of the Civil War in 1865 the Robert’s faction were convinced that the Washington officials of the victorious North were in no mood to enforce neutrality laws. What better way for the I.R.A.(Irish Republican Army) to get even with Great Britain than to capture British North America’s colonies - Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia for a start!
Writer’s Note: This writer has examined the American Civil War through visitations to battle sites and numerous articles for the Review. The North with its powerful Union Army led by General Ulysses S. Grant emerged victorious in April 1865. Grant noted that many of the Union army regiments were made up entirely of Irish men. So? The optimism of the Fenian Brotherhood’s leaders grew immensely as a result of the crushing North victory. Funds began pouring into its coffers. We read that they began to draw up more grandiose plans for the conquest of Canada, The Fenian leaders in 1865 believed that they had the expertise to wage a successful attack on Canada won by the success of “their boys in blue”. It was expected that once the invasion began several thousand men of Irish desert would desert the standing British military force in the colonies. Note: This never happened. If it had it would mean that fewer than 50,000 British regulars would be left for the defence of Canada. The optimism of the Fenians was unabated - Canada, they believed, was theirs for the taking!
Next: Part Four: What do we do?

Fenian Invasion Part 2

Who were the Fenians? by Earl Plato
In the 1860’s smart politicians in the Northeastern U.S.A. saw that this Irish “clannishness” helped to deliver the Irish vote as a block. One of the best ways to maintain this Irish cohesiveness was to encourage the Fenian plan for another Irish revolution against Great Britain. We read that where there was a large Irish population congressmen would have “a legitimate political” reason for ignoring the enforcement of neutrality laws. Other congressmen not dependent on the Irish vote for their seats also openly sympathized with the Fenians’ plan to free Ireland. Historian Walker stated,“ The Revolutionary War and the War of 1812 had left a reservoir of resentment between England (Great Britain) that had not fully evaporated.” Many young Irish Americans joined Union militia companies to gain military training in preparation for a revolution in Ireland. Men like Stephens had assured them that would soon be launched. Irish militia such as the New York “Fighting 69th Regiment were among the first at the front in the American Civil War. The Irish were fierce fighters.
Writers’ note: It is estimated over 2 million men of Irish descent fought for the North’s Union Army - 1861-65.
Fenian Brotherhood agents recruited heavily at home and Irish emigrants increased markedly during the war. Government officials in Washington were pleased with the large flow of badly needed manpower for the Union Army. They were grateful to the Fenian Brotherhood for doing something that official Washington could not do openly. The British, with substantial economic ties to the Confederate South, pointed out that the recruiting in Ireland by the Fenian Brotherhood broke neutrality laws between the U.S.A. and them. Washington officials, including President Lincoln and Secretary Seward, said it was difficult to preserve neutrality when the British had not prevented the warship Alabama and other cruisers from leaving British ports to fight for the South against the North. By the end of the Civil War relations between the United States and Britain had become strained.
The Fenian leaders on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean believed the time had come to begin the great revolution against the British. Large sums of money and many Civil War seasoned military officers were sent back to form the I.R.A. Yes, those letters say the Irish Republican Army. The Fenians were not able to smuggle enough military supplies and the revolt failed.
Part Three: What about Canada?

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Fenian Raid at Fort Erie Part 1


by Earl Plato
It was 141 years this past June 2nd, 2007 that the Fenians fought our Canadian troops at the Battle of Ridgeway.
Who were the Fenians and what prompted this attack?
Writer’s note: This is a synopsis of a series of articles I wrote 16 years ago. That was the year of the Re-enactment held on the Ridgeway battlefield. It was attended by many onlookers. Many of us have good memories of those warm summer-like days and David Owen’s stirring narrative
***
It is simply stated by some writers that the Fenian Movement began on St. Patrick’s day in 1858 by one James Stephens. However, there are other historical writers such as Mabel Walker in her book, The Fenian Movement and Hereward Senior in his work, The Fenians and Canadians. who go back further in Irish history to account for the creation of this revolutionary movement known as the Fenian Brotherhood. Following the terrible Potato Famine in Ireland (1845-1847) in which hundreds of thousands died. There was an unsuccessful Irish revolt against British rule in1848. Emigration from Ireland to North America greatly increased at that time. It was estimated that over two million of them came to the United States by 1865. Most of these newcomers settled in the industrial North eastern states. This was the time when the demand for labourers was growing. The earlier settlers of that area were leaving for new lands in the western U.S.A. Employers welcomed the Irish immigrants as replacements. History recorded, however, that there were others who saw the newcomers with “jaundiced eyes.” The native-born Protestant population of the north eastern states who had not followed the exodus to the American west deplored the increasing number of Roman Catholic churches and parochial schools. One writer of that day stated “ We objected to the noisy celebrations the Irish held on Sundays.” The ostracized Irish reacted to the openly displayed Protestant prejudice by forming societies which “became exceedingly clannish.”
Next: The Fenian Brotherhood